Wine Spectator ~ 94 Points
"Almost as excellent as the 2003. There's intense botrytis spice on the nose, with lemon peel and dried pineapple. Full-bodied, superspicy and intense. Extremely racy. A beautiful wine."
Stephen Tanzer's International Wine Cellar ~ 94 Points
Penetrating and perfumed in the mouth, with terrific cut and energy to its mineral-driven stone and citrus fruit flavors. (..). Wonderfully balanced, deep, very long wine with terrific finishing grip and aromatic clarity.
Jean-Marc Quarin ~ 93 Points
"Very supple, meticulous, the wine develops aromatic, strong and spicy, toward a subtly liquoreuse finish. Amazingly aromatic persistence. The balance is in favor of sweetness. Very good."
Jean-Marc Quarin ~ 100 Points
"On the palate, it is marvelous and melts gracefully with nuances before finishing ethereal. I have never known this growth so subtle and full both at the same time. It is a great, great wine!"